The Grade Card, explained and applied

Five marks, asked in the same order every time. A case study that hides a bad mark is marketing. This page is built so a weak mark has somewhere to sit.

What each mark is really asking

Valuation asks whether the asking price is supported by evidence, not by scarcity language. Area Transformation asks which changes to the surroundings are documented and dated, and which are hopeful. Lifestyle Demand asks who wants to live here daily rather than who might theoretically rent it. Upside Catalysts asks for named, datable events instead of a general sense of growth. Exit Strategy asks the question most buyers postpone: who buys this from you, and at what price, when you want out.

A project can be strong on three marks and thin on two, and still be right for a particular household. That judgement is only possible once the thin marks are written down.

The Grade Card

The template every case study below is built from.

Valuation
What the price is doing against comparable transactions, not against the brochure.
Area Transformation
Which planned works and land parcels actually change the neighbourhood, and by when.
Lifestyle Demand
Who genuinely wants to live here every day, and what they will pay to do so.
Upside Catalysts
The specific, datable events that could lift the unit, separated from wishful reading.
Exit Strategy
Who buys this from you in year five, and what has to be true for them to show up.

Case studies

Two developments are structured below. Nothing has been graded yet: no scores, no figures, no photographs and no commentary will appear until the analysis is done and the material is supplied.

Lucerne Grand

Case study structure only. No analysis has been written for this development yet.

Project overview
Content to be supplied
Buyer profile considered
Content to be supplied
Comparable transactions reviewed
Content to be supplied
Where this project is weak
Content to be supplied

Grade Card: Lucerne Grand

Grades to be supplied

Valuation
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied
Area Transformation
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied
Lifestyle Demand
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied
Upside Catalysts
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied
Exit Strategy
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied

Thomson Reserve

Case study structure only. No analysis has been written for this development yet.

Project overview
Content to be supplied
Buyer profile considered
Content to be supplied
Comparable transactions reviewed
Content to be supplied
Where this project is weak
Content to be supplied

Grade Card: Thomson Reserve

Grades to be supplied

Valuation
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied
Area Transformation
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied
Lifestyle Demand
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied
Upside Catalysts
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied
Exit Strategy
Grade to be suppliedContent to be supplied

Want your own shortlist put through the same five marks?